| Year | School | Player Name |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | Stevenson University | Jack McKenna |
| 2020 | Nazareth College | Reece Wieder |
| 2020 | Neumann University | Anthony Tarquini |
| 2020 | Neumann University | Justice Brovero |
| 2020 | Florida Southern | Joey Heckel |
| 2020 | Elizabethtown College | Lucca Scomillio |
| 2020 | St. John Fisher | Logan Grom |
| 2020 | Arcadia University | Christian Chiulli |
| 2020 | Chestnut Hill College | Thomas Austin |
| 2019 | Wagner College | Eli Fisher |
| 2019 | Kean University | Max Stevens |
| 2019 | Chatham University | Clark Styles |
| 2019 | Stevens Institute of Technology | Joey Cerar |
| 2019 | Swarthmore College | David Akinsooto |
| 2019 | Dickinson College | Seamus McCloskey |
| 2019 | Del Val University | Alex Axman |
| 2019 | Widener University | Brian Noll |
| 2019 | Haverford College | Christian Pfennig |
| 2019 | Hood College | Todd Gloss |
| 2019 | Elizabethtown | Joey Pasquale |
| 2019 | Chestnut Hill | Mike Smith |
| 2019 | Ursinus College | Matt Sy |
| 2019 | Elizabethtown | Ryan Flanegan |
| 2019 | Widener University | Sabino Basso |
| 2019 | Keiser University | Spencer Patton |
| 2019 | Susquehanna University | Ryan Prum |
| 2019 | Chestnut Hill College | Mike Smith |
| 2019 | Arcadia University | Nate Oraschin |
| 2019 | Arcadia University | Nolan Chiulli |
| 2018 | Misericordia University | Ian Haggerty |
| 2018 | Moravian College | RJ Guffy |
| 2018 | Hood College | Michael Hilliard |
| 2018 | Dominican College | Garrett Wilson |
| 2018 | Union College | Reed Karaska |
| 2018 | Mars Hill University | Gaige Swallow |
| 2018 | Wilkes University | Tyler Knappenberger |
| 2018 | Georgetown University | Naveen Ailawadi |
| 2018 | Manhattanville College | Christian Miccio |
| 2018 | Emerson College | Jack Lewis |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Marquette | Cade Stratton | 2017 |
| Georgetown | Cade Heverly | 2017 |
| Monmouth | Brock Anderson | 2017 |
| Seton Hill | Kevin Mo | 2017 |
| Roanoke | Leroy Moser | 2017 |
| Widener | Chad Allison | 2017 |
| Widener | Nick Diiorio | 2017 |
| Marquette | Zach Granger | 2017 |
| RPI | Jason Bram |
2017 |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Dartmouth | David Gallagher | 2016 |
| Marist | Steve Viola | 2016 |
| Franklin and Marshall | Robby Baxter | 2016 |
| Hartford | Alex Bonnett | 2016 |
| High Point | Tyler Kostack | 2016 |
| Marquette | Ryan Granger | 2016 |
| Army | Karl Van Blargan | 2016 |
| St. John's | Pat Smyth | 2016 |
| Cabrini | Ty Moschella | 2016 |
| Gwynedd Mercy | Peter Fabiani | 2016 |
| Monmouth | Zach Granger | 2016 |
| Wooster | Marco Peticca | 2016 |
| Cleveland State | Jack Feeney | 2016 |
| Cabrini | Mike Gerzabek | 2016 |
| Lycoming | Sam Pollock | 2016 |
| Tampa | Connor McGuigan | 2016 |
| Muhlenberg | Drew Rafferty | 2016 |
| Bates | Frankie Spitz | 2016 |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Ursinus | Timmy Miller | 2015 |
| Ursinus | Brian Casey | 2015 |
| Chestnut Hill | Blaise Fugazzotto | 2015 |
| Coast Guard | Matt Nagle | 2015 |
| Swarthmore | Bryan Murray | 2015 |
| Cabrini | Bill Morgan | 2015 |
| Mount St. Mary's | Mike Risser | 2015 |
| Marquette | Noah Richard | 2015 |
| Gettysburg | Chris Verdeur | 2015 |
| Dickinson | Hal Marshall | 2015 |
| Cabrini | TJ Reiley | 2015 |
| Wagner | Shane Taylor | 2015 |
| Colgate | Jack Donaghue | 2015 |
| Drexel | Nolan Fox | 2015 |
| Drexel | Nick Fox | 2015 |
| St. John's | Colin Duffy | 2015 |
| Fairfield | Sam Gindhart | 2015 |
| High Point | Mike Cropper | 2015 |
| St. Joe's | Dan Lanham | 2015 |
| Navy | Colin Bosak | 2015 |
| Lehigh | Luc Spence | 2015 |
| Hofstra | Jon Warg | 2015 |
| Hofstra | John Lyman | 2015 |
| Elizabethtown | Andrew Watts | 2015 |
| Stockton | Ryan Bradley | 2015 |
tr>
| College/Univsersity | Name | Grad Year |
| Holy Cross | Will Friedman | 2014 |
| RPI | Jack Muliawan | 2014 |
| Widener | John Ferguson | 2014 |
| Cabrini | Nile Luma | 2014 |
| Eastern | Bryan Mizell | 2014 |
| Widener | Anthony Paone | 2014 |
| York | Ryan Cook | 2014 |
| Wingate | Chris Gazzio | 2014 |
| Cabrini | Joey Hoey | 2014 |
| Hobart | Alex Ataiifar | 2014 |
| Lafayette | Owen Green | 2014 |
| Denison | Cullen Dussinger | 2014 |
| St. John's | Jack Glemser | 2014 |
| UMBC | Max Haldeman | 2014 |
| Quinnipiac | Jack Haney | 2014 |
| St. John's | John Saunders | 2014 |
| St. Joe's | Jake Matier | 2014 |
| Villanova | Sean Delaney | 2014 |
| Jacksonville | Ryan Beville | 2014 |
| Robert Morris | Alex Arhontoulis | 2014 |
| Lafayette | Jack App | 2014 |
| Army | David Sickler | 2014 |
| Penn | Connor Keating | 2014 |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Elizabethtown | Steve Onorato | 2013 |
| DeSales | Justin Wilson | 2013 |
| Cabrini | Alex Dipasquale | 2013 |
| Cabrini | Steve Halko | 2013 |
| Chestnut Hill | Mark Pascetta | 2013 |
| Cabrini | Mike Crowley | 2013 |
| Hartford | DJ Young | 2013 |
| Delaware | Rupert Ortlieb | 2013 |
| Catholic | Tony Fisher | 2013 |
| Albright | Derek Stump | 2013 |
| Monmouth | Andrew Grajewski | 2013 |
| Chestnut Hill | Tom McDermott | 2013 |
| Widener | Sean Sauder | 2013 |
| Ursinus | Brock D'Annunzio | 2013 |
| Ursinus | Zach Jones | 2013 |
| Ohio Wesleyan | Dan Ehrlichman | 2013 |
| Bellarmine | Matt Taulane | 2013 |
| St. Joe's | Mike Lanham | 2013 |
| Wagner | Christian McCormick | 2013 |
| Dickinson | Dalton George | 2013 |
| Colgate | Chase Cowan | 2013 |
| Navy | Ryan Kelly | 2013 |
| Marquette | Nick Eufrasio | 2013 |
| Marquette | Joe Dunn | 2013 |
| Mount St. Mary's | Kelton Heverly | 2013 |
| Cabrini | Nick Tordone | 2013 |
| Marquette | Noah Joseph | 2013 |
| Delaware | Gavin Weaver | 2013 |
| St. John's | Dante Addona | 2013 |
| St. John's | Dan Smyth | 2013 |
| Denver | Joey Ward | 2013 |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Brown | Will Gural | 2012 |
| Loyola | Kyle Gangemi | 2012 |
| Marist | Patrick Stepek | 2012 |
| Marquette | Jacob Richard | 2012 |
| Marquette | Blaine Flemming | 2012 |
| Michigan | Rob Zonino | 2012 |
| Michigan | Paxton Moore | 2012 |
| Navy | Kevin Samolsky | 2012 |
| St. Joseph's | Patrick Swanick | 2012 |
| Hofstra | Joe Baker | 2012 |
| Marquette | Matt Barone | 2012 |
| Loyola | Justin Verratti | 2012 |
| Mount St. Mary's | Frankie McCarthy | 2012 |
| Trinity | Henry Coote | 2012 |
| Notre Dame | Jack Sheridan | 2012 |
| Washington and Lee | Grame Weaver | 2012 |
| Robert Morris | Eric Rankel | 2012 |
| Ursinus | James Fairchild | 2012 |
| Amherst | Sam Lawlor | 2012 |
| Cabrini | Ryan Poole | 2012 |
| Cabrini | Eric Streicher | 2012 |
| Cabrini | Sebastian Kerslake | 2012 |
| Washington College | Jake Glancy | 2012 |
| Washington College | Kevin Griffiths | 2012 |
| Lehigh | Casey Eidenshink | 2012 |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Brown | R. Brent Tomlinson | 2011 |
| Johns Hopkins | Andrew Kennedy | 2011 |
| Lafayette | Keegan Lawton | 2011 |
| Lafayette | Cory Scheuerle | 2011 |
| Marquette | Daniel Mojica | 2011 |
| Navy | Beau Gomez | 2011 |
| Navy | Russell Atkinson | 2011 |
| Navy | TJ Hanzsche | 2011 |
| Quinnipiac | Evan Weldon | 2011 |
| St. Joseph's | Will Farrell | 2011 |
| UMass | Vincent Travaglini | 2011 |
| Dickinson | Colin Farrell | 2011 |
| Lynchburg | Evan Leeder | 2011 |
| Roanoke | Wesley Pancoast | 2011 |
| Marquette | Matt Barone | 2011 |
| Roanoke | Ryan Brewer | 2011 |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Cornell | Beau Brady | 2010 |
| Duke | Henry Lobb | 2010 |
| Georgetown | Tyler Johnston | 2010 |
| Georgetown | Bryson Craft | 2010 |
| Ohio State | Shawn Kaplan | 2010 |
| Robert Morris | Tyler Rankel | 2010 |
| St. Joseph's | Jack Moran | 2010 |
| UNC | Ryan Creighton | 2010 |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Brown | Wills Curley | 2009 |
| Bryant | John Pirier | 2009 |
| Bucknell | Wills Miller | 2009 |
| Cornell | Paul Mita | 2009 |
| Delaware | James Connelly | 2009 |
| Lafayette | William Heffernan | 2009 |
| Mount St. Mary's | Daniel Stranix | 2009 |
| Penn State | Cole Yeager | 2009 |
| St. Joseph's | Ian Correia | 2009 |
| UMass | Colin Fleming | 2009 |
| UNC | Conor Steidle | 2009 |
| Villanova | Harte Thompson | 2009 |
| College/University | Name | Grad Year |
| Brown | Andrew Feinberg | 2008 |
| Dartmouth | Ben Rossman | 2008 |
| Drexel | Mark Manos | 2008 |
| Lafayette | Alexander Floeck | 2008 |
| Loyola | Steve Layne | 2008 |
| Penn State | Alex Gannett | 2008 |
| Siena | Mike Scott | 2008 |
| St. John's | Charles Holenstein | 2008 |
| St. John's | John McSorley | 2008 |
| Villanova | Chris Creighton | 2008 |
| Villanova | Brendan O'Donnell | 2008 |
| Wagner | Mike Scheerer | 2008 |